Petition for review granted on grounds that witnesses who testify against gang members may constitute a particular social group despite a lack of social visibility.
Petition for review granted, order vacated
and decision remanded for proceedings to establish clarity with regards to rejection of claimant's past persecution claim and basing decision on the legal principle that past persecution to family members can be the basis for a past persecution claim.
EOIR held the applicant had established well founded fear of persecution on account of her membership in a particular social group comprised of members of her family (family targeted for persecution by an El Salvadoran gang, MS-13).