i) an Order pursuant to s.4 Human Rights Act 1998 declaring that sections 20-37
of the Immigration Act 2014 are incompatible with Article 14 ECHR in
conjunction with Article 8 ECHR; and
56
ii) An Order declaring that a decision by the Defendant to commence the Scheme
represented by sections 20-37 of the Immigration Act 2014 in Scotland, Wales
or Northern Ireland without further evaluation of its efficacy and
discriminatory impact would be irrational and would constitute a breach of s.
149 Equality Act 2010.
At issue are the reach of the Refugees Act and of the Immigration Act as well as the interplay between these two statutes; the effect of delay on entitlement to apply for refugee status; the operation of the exclusionary provisions of the Refugees Act, particularly section 4(1)(b); and whether this section applies only to crimes committed outside South Africa. Also at issue is the fidelity of the Supreme Court of Appeal to its own judgments and whether in this case commitment to precedent (stare decisis) was breached.